Real Estate Transactions on Shelter Island: October 2025

December 29, 2025 - 22:03

Recent real estate transactions on Shelter Island reveal a mix of residential sales, showcasing the ongoing interest in this picturesque location. A notable transaction involved the Myron Zisser Trust selling a property at 21 Congdon Road to Thomas Eagan and Michael Lubin for $1.5 million. This sale reflects the high demand for homes in the area, particularly those with desirable locations and amenities.

In another transaction, Todd and Melissa Taylor sold their property at 1 Shorewood Road to Todd Taylor for $120,000. This deal highlights the diverse range of property values on Shelter Island, catering to various buyers and investors.

As the real estate market continues to evolve, these transactions indicate a robust interest in Shelter Island, attracting both new residents and seasoned homeowners. The community remains a sought-after destination for those looking to enjoy its unique charm and scenic beauty.